Margaret Ellen Scholl

In Loving Memory of Peggy Scholl

Margaret "Peggy" Ellen Scholl entered into the arms of her precious Savior on February 3, 2026, passing peacefully at 5:55 a.m. A resident of Sylvania, Ohio, Peggy was a woman of incredible soul who spent her life as a living testament to God’s unconditional love.

Born in Hoboken, NJ, and having spent her young adulthood in Los Angeles, Peggy eventually brought her vibrant spirit to Ohio. Throughout every season of her life, she possessed a tremendous heart for Jesus. Her faith was a radiant force; family and friends often remarked that when Peggy entered a room, she didn't just light it up with her physical smile – though her smile was indeed incredible – she illuminated every space with a spiritual light and love that she poured into every person she met.

As a wife, Peggy’s love, support, and unwavering faith in Jesus was the bedrock of their marriage. Her love for Craig was entirely unconditional. She stood steadfastly by his side in his pastoral duties, often joining him to visit members of the congregation in their homes and at the hospital. Peggy was the living example of walking Jesus’s path; she was the quiet, constant embodiment of the love they shared in Jesus. When Craig’s ministry called him away, Peggy stepped in as the primary parent, ensuring their sons were always supported, nurtured, and loved.

As a mother, Peggy was truly special. Her ability to listen, love, and teach was beyond measure. That maternal love extended far beyond her two sons to include all of their friends and every child at her church. She was a woman who never judged; she had a rare gift for making anyone feel heard and loved in a way that could ease any troubled heart. Peggy was a trusted confidant, a steady shoulder to lean on, and a constant voice of encouragement through life's darkest and brightest moments.

Peggy’s ministry of service was often shared with her "best friends" and partners in work. Alongside her cherished Irish Wolfhounds – Milo, Bentley, and Tara – and her faithful Border Terrier, Nautie, Peggy served as a therapy dog handler. Together, they brought comfort and peace to children and adults in hospitals, libraries, and senior facilities.

Beyond her therapy work, Peggy was a devoted mentor to young adults at Memorial Lutheran Church, where she also led Sunday School and shared her heart through children’s sermons, organizing the holiday meal program, kids' night and the children’s Christmas program. She was never too busy to give back, and she loved in a way that taught everyone around her what it truly means to be "God’s love" in the flesh.

Peggy is preceded in death by her mother, Margaret Normoore; her father, Harold Bontz; and her brothers, Raymond Ayala, Joseph Moore, and John Moore.

Her legacy of love continues through her husband, Craig; her sons, John Michael (Melissa) and Karl (Sara); and her beloved granddaughters, Eleanor, Veda, and Willow. She is also survived by her sister-in-law, Debbie (Roger), and her nieces and nephews, Trisha, Craig, Brad, Lisa, Jodi, Jill, and Jenna, all of whom she loved dearly.

In her final years, Peggy fought a valiant and courageous 12-year battle with Alzheimer’s. Even as the disease sought to dim her world, she remained a profound inspiration to everyone around her. She faced her struggle with a quiet dignity and a resilience that moved those who cared for her, proving that while the illness could cloud the mind, it could never touch the brilliant essence of her soul. Her journey was a final lesson in grace, showing us, all that God’s light shines brightest in the most difficult of seasons. We take comfort in knowing her light and love remains undimmed in the hearts of those she touched. Her family would like to extend a special thanks to the entire staff at Memory Lane Care Services along with the Hospice of Northwest Ohio for their service and grace to support us and so many in this battle. They were a consistent source of love and care, providing another community in love for Peggy to share her joy, light, and love.

Those wishing to offer memorials, in lieu of flowers, are asked to consider Memory Lane Care Services 2500 N. Reynolds Rd. Toledo, OH43615, or the charity of the donor’s choice.

Service Information: Visitation: Friday, February 20, 2026, from 3:00 p.m. – 7:00 p.m. at Reeb Funeral Home.

Funeral Service: Saturday, February 21, 2026, at St. Stephen Lutheran Church. (Visitation from 1:00 p.m. – 2:00 p.m.; Service begins at 2:00 p.m.).

To send flowers to the family or plant a tree in memory of Margaret Ellen Scholl, please visit our floral store.